Commentary: What's Real and Make-Believe with the RIAA Subpoenas?
Pages: 1, 2
The "Clean Slate" Amnesty Program
On Monday, September 8, 2003, the RIAA announced that it has filed lawsuits against 261 people. It also announced its "Clean Slate" Amnesty program on MusicUnited.org.
To participate, sharers would fill out the Clean Slate Affidavit stating that all infringing files have been deleted from their computer and all CDs burned from those files have been destroyed. In addition, confessors would pledge to never do it again with the understanding that the penalties would be even more severe if they were caught, because they could then be charged with "willful infringement."
The affidavits must be notarized, and there must be a separate affidavit for everyone in your household. Sharers under 18 must have the affidavit signed by their parent or guardian. Applicants are also expected to "not allow others to illegally download copyrighted sound recordings to your computer(s)." Only individuals are eligible for the Clean Slate program; businesses, groups, organizations or "entities," or individuals who traded for payment or commercial purposes may not participate.
In the program description, in exchange for filling out and sending in an affidavit, the RIAA will agree "not to support or assist in copyright infringement suits based on past conduct" for users who meet certain conditions. One of these conditions is the RIAA "has not begun to investigate you by requesting from an Internet Service Provider (ISP), by subpoena or otherwise, identifying information about you." If users whose information has already been subpoenaed are not eligible for amnesty, this presents a problem for any users wishing to receive amnesty. Under the DMCA, neither the RIAA or the ISP who has been subpoenaed is required to notify the user upon being served, they could unknowingly admit to conduct the RIAA might already be in the process of suing them for.
A key issue remains that the RIAA does not even have the right to grant full amnesty in the first place. The songwriters and music publishers that aren't represented by the RIAA (such as Metallica) could opt to sue infringers on their own. "The RIAA doesn't have the right to give full amnesty for file sharing. True, they represent 90% of all sound recording copyright owners. But there are still 10 percent out there who could sue you even if you take amnesty program," said Jason Schultz, a staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation. "It's still unclear if amnesty saves you from being sued by the songwriters/music publishers."
"We're calling it a 'Shamnesty.' It's more like a Trojan Horse than a 'clean slate.' It fools you into thinking you're safe, when the reality is that, if anything, you're more at risk for participating," explains Jason Schultz, Staff Attorney for the EFF. "It's not 'Full Amnesty' at all. The agreement doesn't give file sharers any real peace of mind, because it only covers being sued by the RIAA itself -- not any of its member companies. This means that, under the Clean Slate agreement, recording companies, copyright owners, and music publishers can all still sue you. It only means that the RIAA won't 'assist' them in the lawsuit. They are basically getting you to admit to the conduct so your own statement can be used against you later."
- EFF's "Stop The RIAA" Petition
- Theofel vs. Farey-Jones Decision (Kozinski Decision)
- The EFF's Subpoena Database Query Tool, The Electronic Frontier Foundation
- "How Not To Get Sued By The RIAA For File Sharing," The Electronic Frontier Foundation
- Clean Slate Program Description (.pdf)
- Clean Slate Program Affidavit (.pdf)
- Letter to RIAA President Cary Sherman from the Net Coalition (.pdf)
- Interview With Norm Coleman in Future Tense Now Magazine (.mp3)
- "Recording Industry Sues File Swappers," David McGuire, Washington Post
- "Record Labels To Offer Amnesty to File Sharers, With Conditions," Jon Healy, LA Times
- "Peace Offering For File Traders?," Katie Dean, Wired News
- "Internet Legislation Upsetting Film Studios," Jon Healey, LA Times
- "RIAA Offers P2P Users No-Win Amnesty"
- "Sources: RIAA To Give File Sharers Amnesty"
- "Music Industry to Unveil Amnesty Offer," Ted Bridis, Associated Press
- Letter from Norm Coleman (.pdf), Also available in HTML
- Spoof On Clean Slate Affidavit, Users Are Friendly
- Details of the RIAA's Amnesty Program
Return to OpenP2P.com.
- Trackback from http://george.hotelling.net/90percent/digital_music/riaa_shock_troops.php
RIAA Shock Troops
2003-12-13 16:11:50 [View]
2003-09-12 16:48:09 anonymous2 [View]